Weigh the Decision
The exam gives you three options and a booklet of sources. Learn the skill of weighing physical and human impacts, using the evidence, and justifying a clear choice.
Revise this, the fun way
Play it interactively, earn XP and build a streak, free.
Start revising freeWhat you'll cover
Three options, one choice 🗳️
In the exam you are given a booklet of sources about a real geographical issue, and THREE possible decisions. Your job is to weigh them up, choose ONE, and justify it in a longer answer. This unit has no facts to learn. The **skill** of making a good decision is the whole thing.
Words to know 🔑
Four ideas run through this skill:
A strong answer 🎯
What makes a strong decision answer?
- It weighs both physical and human impacts, using the sources
- It picks an option at random
- It ignores the sources and just gives an opinion
- It only ever looks at the cost
Two kinds of impact ⚖️
Every option has effects. Weigh both kinds before you choose.
Physical or human? 🔗
- A new scheme drains a wetland
- A scheme creates local jobs
- A rare bird habitat is lost
- Some families must move home
- A physical impact on the environment
- A human benefit for people
- A physical cost to nature
- A human cost to a community
The golden rule 📋
A top answer does three things: it USES the sources as evidence, it weighs BOTH physical and human impacts, and it makes a clear JUSTIFIED choice. Avoid a vague ending like on balance with no reasons. Back every point with evidence.
What makes it strong? ✅
Which THREE make a decision answer strong?
- It uses evidence from the sources
- It weighs physical and human impacts
- It justifies the final choice
- It chooses an option at random
- It ends with a vague on balance
Which is physical? 🔎
Which of these is a physical impact of a scheme?
- A river ecosystem is damaged
- Local people gain new jobs
- The scheme costs a lot of money
- Families have to move home
Make the decision 🪜
An interactive activity.
Complete the idea 🧩
In a decision-making exam you read a booklet of _____ and choose one option from _____. A good answer weighs the _____ impacts on the environment against the _____ impacts on people. You must back your choice with clear _____, not a vague opinion.
True or not? 🖍️
An interactive activity.
Weigh the options 🔀
- Build a high concrete flood wall
- Restore a natural wetland upstream
- Do nothing and save the money
- Help families move to safer ground
- Strong protection, but costly and ugly
- Cheap and green, but slower to work
- Saves money now, but risks future floods
- Keeps people safe, but breaks up a community
You decide 🧭
An interactive activity.
Plan your decision ✍️
An interactive activity.