Aims of Punishment and Forgiveness
The four aims of punishment (protection, retribution, deterrence and reformation) and how Muslims hold justice together with mercy, forgiveness and restorative justice.
Put it to work, not just to memory
Free and interactive, so you are arguing with the material rather than rereading it.
Start revising freeWhat you'll cover
Punishment and forgiveness
When someone commits a crime, what should happen next? Societies punish criminals, but they do so for different aims. Islam teaches that justice matters, but so does mercy and forgiveness. This module looks at the four aims of punishment, and at how Muslims balance punishing wrongdoing with the call to forgive.
The four aims of punishment
Punishment can have four main aims:
Match the aim
- Protection
- Retribution
- Deterrence
- Reformation
- Keeping society safe from the criminal
- The criminal deserves to pay back for the wrong
- Putting people off committing crime in future
- Changing the criminal so they do not reoffend
Which aim?
A judge gives a long sentence mainly to keep a dangerous criminal away from the public. Which aim of punishment is this?
- Protection
- Retribution
- Deterrence
- Reformation
A Muslim view of justice
Islam teaches that justice is very important: the Qur'an (Surah 4) calls on believers to be fair and to stand up for justice, even where it is difficult. Many Muslims accept punishment for the four aims above, but they also stress that punishment should be fair and proportionate, and that the door to repentance and reform should stay open.
Aims of punishment
Select the TWO that are recognised aims of punishment.
- Deterrence, to put people off crime
- Reformation, to change the criminal for the better
- Personal revenge taken by the victim
- Making the government wealthy
Justice and forgiveness
Islam holds justice and forgiveness together. Both matter.
The aims in words
Punishment has four main aims. _____ keeps society safe. _____ means the criminal deserves to pay back. _____ tries to put people off future crime. _____ tries to change the criminal for the better. Alongside justice, Islam stresses mercy and _____.
Islam and forgiveness
What does Islam teach about forgiveness?
- Muslims are encouraged to forgive those who are truly sorry
- Muslims must never forgive any crime
- Victims are forced to forgive at once
- Only leaders are allowed to forgive
Restorative justice
Restorative justice tries to repair harm. Put its steps into a sensible order.
- The offender admits the harm they have caused
- The offender and victim meet, if the victim agrees
- The offender listens to how the crime affected the victim
- The offender apologises and makes amends
- The victim and community begin to heal
Weigh the aims
For each case, choose the aim of punishment that fits best.
- A court jails a violent offender mainly to keep the public safe. Which aim is this?
- An offender is given education and training in prison to help them start afresh. Which aim is this?
- A judge gives a tough, well-publicised sentence to warn others not to commit the same crime. Which aim is this?
Justice and mercy
For a serious crime, explain which aim of punishment you think matters most, and explain how a Muslim might also want forgiveness to play a part. Write in clear, full sentences.
- Name the four aims of punishment
- Choose one aim you think matters most for a serious crime, and give a reason
- Explain how Islam values mercy and forgiveness alongside justice
- Show that you understand both justice and forgiveness