Plate Tectonics: Evidence and Boundaries
Nobody has ever watched a plate cross an ocean. Learn how geologists read the theory, and every plate boundary, from the record the rocks leave behind.
Get the method right under pressure
Free interactive practice on the steps that lose marks under exam pressure.
Start revising freeWhat you'll cover
Nobody has watched a plate cross an ocean
Plates move about as fast as your fingernails grow. Nobody has ever stood and watched one travel, and nobody has seen the layer underneath that lets it move. So everything in this topic is an inference from a record. Rocks, magnetism, earthquakes and the shape of the land each keep a record of what happened, and geologists work backwards from it. You will use that move twice: - On the whole theory. How did geologists get from "the continents look as if they fit" to a theory almost every geologist accepts? - On a single boundary. Given a map or some data, which kind of boundary is this, and how are the plates moving? In both cases, the strongest answer names the evidence first and the conclusion second.
Two ways to slice the Earth
The specification asks for both. They cut the Earth at different depths, so learn which question each one answers.
Where does a plate actually end?
A student writes: "Tectonic plates are pieces of the crust sliding over the mantle." Which correction is right?
- A plate is a piece of lithosphere, made of crust and the uppermost mantle, moving over the weaker asthenosphere
- A plate is a piece of mantle sliding over the core
- Nothing is wrong: crust and plate mean the same thing
- The mantle under a plate is liquid, so the plate floats on it
How the sceptics were won
1915: Wegener proposes continental drift. He pointed to how well the coasts of South America and Africa fit together, and to the same fossil species on continents that are now separated by ocean. Most geologists rejected the idea. The problem was not his evidence; it was that he could not explain what force could push whole continents through solid rock. The answer came from the ocean floor, which Wegener could not study. 1960: Hess proposed sea floor spreading. New ocean floor forms at the mid-ocean ridges and moves away on both sides, so the continents are carried along rather than ploughing through anything. 1963: Vine and Matthews explained the magnetic pattern on the sea floor. Bands of rock either side of a ridge record the Earth's magnetic field in alternating directions, and the pattern on one side is a mirror image of the other. 1965: J. Tuzo Wilson described transform faults, the boundaries where plates slide past each other. That completed the set of ways plates can meet. Since then, satellite positioning has measured the movement directly, year by year. Notice the shift: the early evidence showed the continents had been together; the later evidence showed how they came apart, and that they are still moving.
Sort the evidence by what it proves
Each piece of evidence supports plate tectonics in a different way. Sort each one by what it actually shows.
- The edges of two continents fit like jigsaw pieces
- The same land-living fossil species on continents an ocean apart
- Magnetic bands that mirror each other either side of a ridge
- Ocean floor that is youngest at the ridge and older with distance
- Unusually high heat flow along the ridge crest
- Satellite measurements of two stations drifting apart year on year
Build a magnetic stripe
Put these events in order to show how the mirrored bands either side of a ridge are made.
- Partial melting of the upper mantle beneath the ridge produces basalt magma
- The basalt cools at the ridge and locks in the direction of the Earth's magnetic field
- The new rock is split and carried away on both sides of the ridge
- The Earth's magnetic field reverses
- The next basalt to cool records the opposite direction
- Matching bands now lie at equal distances either side of the ridge
Why Wegener lost the first argument
Select the TWO statements that explain why continental drift was rejected in Wegener's time but plate tectonics was accepted later.
- He could not explain what force could move continents through solid rock
- The decisive evidence came from the ocean floor, which could not be studied in detail in his time
- Later surveys showed that the continents do not fit together after all
- His fossils turned out to be different species on each continent
Read the boundary from its record
Each kind of boundary leaves a different combination of magma, earthquakes and landforms. Learn the combination, not just the name.
What would you find here?
Match each picture to the record a geologist would expect to find there. One record fits none of them.
- Basalt lava, shallow earthquakes and high heat flow
- Frequent shallow earthquakes but no volcanic rock at all
- Andesite volcanoes, and earthquakes that get deeper inland
- Granite, folded rock and regional metamorphism, but no ocean floor
Three collisions, three different records
Convergent boundaries are where most marks are lost, because the three kinds look alike on a map. Ask one question first: can either plate sink? - Ocean meets ocean. One ocean plate sinks beneath the other. You get a deep trench and, beside it, a curved chain of volcanic islands: an island arc. - Ocean meets continent. The ocean plate sinks beneath the continent. Earthquakes follow the sinking plate down, so they get deeper the further inland you go. That sloping band of earthquakes is the Benioff zone. Melting above it feeds andesitic and granitic magma, and the volcanoes stand on land. - Continent meets continent. Neither sinks easily, so the crust is squeezed and thickened instead. The record is mountains, folding, thrust faults, granites from melting crust and regional metamorphism, with little or no volcanic activity at the surface. In an exam answer, name the evidence before the boundary: "earthquakes deepen towards the continent, so a plate is sinking, so this is ocean meeting continent."
Name the boundary from the data
Three field reports. Each describes the record, not the boundary. Decide what each one shows.
- A survey of the sea bed finds a long ridge with a valley along its crest, fresh basalt, shallow earthquakes, and rock that gets older in both directions away from the crest.
- On land, a long straight zone of frequent earthquakes runs straight across the landscape. Streams that cross it are bent sideways. There are no volcanoes anywhere along it.
- A coastal mountain range has active volcanoes erupting andesite. Earthquakes are shallow near the coast and much deeper beneath the mountains inland. Offshore there is a deep trench.
Plate record run
Five questions on layers, evidence and boundaries. Three lives.
Complete the boundary records
The rigid shell that forms the plates is the _____, and it moves over the weaker _____. Where plates slide past each other, the earthquakes happen on _____ faults. The island chain beside an ocean trench is an island _____. The volcanoes of the Andes erupt mainly _____ magma.
Still being tested
The specification says plates move by mechanisms not yet completely understood, and that the theory is continually re-evaluated as new evidence arrives. Two kinds of evidence are named: - Seismic tomography builds pictures of the inside of the Earth from how fast earthquake waves travel through different parts of the mantle. It lets geologists look for what lies beneath plates instead of guessing. - Ocean drilling recovers rock from deep beneath the sea floor that has never been seen at the surface. Research ships such as the RRS James Cook and the JOIDES Resolution (Expedition 360, 2016) have drilled into ocean crust to test ideas about how it forms. This is the same move as the rest of the module. The theory is a conclusion from a record, and a better record can change the conclusion. Saying that in an evaluation answer is a strength, not a weakness.
Turn a reading into an inference
This is the shape of a good data answer: evidence, then what it means, then what else you would expect. Assemble it.
Make the case from the ocean floor
A classmate says plate tectonics is "just a theory" because nobody has seen a plate move. Explain what evidence convinced geologists, and how the same kind of evidence identifies a plate boundary today.
- Wegener and what his case lacked
- Hess, Vine and Matthews, and the ocean floor
- Evidence that plates are moving now
- One boundary named from its record
- What is still being tested