DoRevision

Religion, Medical Ethics and the Value of Life

What you say a human is decides what follows. Compare Christian, Muslim and non-religious accounts of human nature, then trace how each shapes views on when life begins, abortion and euthanasia.

⏱️ 22 min 🎯 16 activities
Best used for
Independent study Mock preparation Cover lesson

Use it, the way the marks are given

Free interactive practice at using the material, which is what the marks are for.

Start revising free

What you'll cover

What is a human?

This module covers the second theme of Unit 3, human nature and the right to life. It deals with abortion and euthanasia, which some learners will have met in their own lives, so every view here is reported, not recommended. The specification sets two linked questions: what makes us human, and what follows for medical ethics. You answer from three perspectives: Christianity or Catholic Christianity, the world religion you study, and non-religious perspectives, which are assessed alongside Christian ones. Islam is the world religion used here. Keep one thread in mind on every step: what someone says a human is shapes what they say may be done. In the exam, showing that link earns far more than listing views for and against.

Five words that carry the debate

These words do the work in this theme. Use them exactly, and say whose word each one is.

Match each idea to someone using it

  • Sanctity of life
  • Ensoulment
  • Niyyah
  • Darar
  • Autonomy
  • A Christian nurse says no illness can lessen what God has given
  • A Muslim scholar asks at which stage of pregnancy a spirit is present
  • A Muslim doctor asks what a colleague was trying to achieve, not only what happened
  • A Muslim family asks which option would hurt everyone the least
  • A patient says that this decision about their body is theirs to make

Two religious accounts of a human

Both religions say humans are more than their bodies, and both trace that back to God. The detail differs, and the detail is what later arguments rest on.

Why are they still fully human?

A patient has been unconscious for months and can no longer reason or choose. A Christian says this person is as fully human as ever. Which reasoning best supports that claim?

  • Their worth rests on who made them, so lost abilities take nothing away
  • Their worth lasts for as long as they could once choose for themselves
  • Their worth is measured by how much they still matter to other people
  • Their worth is guaranteed because the law protects every hospital patient

When does a life begin?

The abortion debate starts with when a human life begins, and each perspective is divided. For many Christians it begins at conception, when the embryo is fully human with inherent dignity and worth (Psalm 139:13-16), while a minority believe full human life begins at birth. Some Muslims say life begins at ensoulment, some when the foetus is physically formed, and some at conception. From there, positions follow. Many Christians oppose abortion as taking an innocent life (Exodus 20:13) and as preventing the plan God has for each life (Jeremiah 1:5). Some accept it in extraordinary circumstances, and some advocate alternatives such as adoption. Catholic teaching calls abortion a grave moral wrong (Evangelium Vitae) and holds, in the Catechism, that life is a fundamental right from conception to natural death. Some Catholics accept abortion in certain circumstances, though this is not official teaching, and the Doctrine of Double Effect allows some procedures in very specific circumstances. Muslims hold different views depending on how they interpret the Quran and Hadith. Taking a life unjustly is a grave sin (Quran 5:32), but niyyah and darar also count, and many Muslims argue there are valid grounds for abortion.

Check the magazine article

A magazine article about abortion in Islam makes five claims. Tap the TWO that match Muslim teaching.

  • Muslims reach different conclusions because they read their sources differently.
  • Every Muslim agrees that a person exists from the very first moment.
  • What someone is aiming at matters, not only what they do.
  • Taking a life without just cause is treated as a minor fault.
  • Islam leaves no room for any grounds for abortion at all.

Starting from reason

Non-religious perspectives describe humans as a defined species, with physical traits such as large brains and the ability to use complex language and symbols. Humans are self-conscious, have autonomy, are moral agents who can tell right from wrong, and can search for meaning and purpose in life. None of that needs God, and it means the value of a human is often tied to these capacities. On abortion, non-religious people take different sides of the pro-choice and pro-life debate. Some argue it should rest on personal autonomy, and some want full access to abortion services as necessary to protect the health of women. Some stress the need for a legal framework. Some believe personhood develops later in pregnancy and so allow early abortions. Many look at the individual situation and its consequences, and some share the concern about a slippery slope that some Christians raise.

Build a paragraph on when life begins

Put the five parts of an evaluation paragraph on "Life begins at conception" in a sensible order.

  • Many Christians agree, because they hold that the embryo is fully human
  • They point to Psalm 139:13-16, which speaks of God at work in the womb
  • However, a minority of Christians believe that full human life begins at birth
  • Some non-religious thinkers go further and say personhood develops later in pregnancy
  • So the answer turns on what each side counts as a person, which is why the debate continues

Which perspective is speaking?

For each statement about human nature, choose the perspective it belongs to. Three lives.

At the end of life

Active euthanasia means deliberately acting to end a life. Passive euthanasia means withholding or withdrawing treatment. Voluntary euthanasia is at the request of the person, and involuntary is not. For many Christians only God should decide when a life ends, and many strongly oppose active euthanasia as ending a life God gave (Exodus 20:13). Palliative care is an opportunity to show love and compassion (Galatians 6:2). Some support passive euthanasia on compassionate grounds, and some fear a slippery slope. Catholic teaching calls euthanasia a grave violation of the law of God (Evangelium Vitae), holds that suffering does not make a life less sacred, and strongly supports hospices. Double Effect allows treatment that may cause death only in very specific situations. Most Muslims agree euthanasia is not permissible, as it intentionally ends a life prematurely (Quran 16:61). Suffering is often viewed as a test to endure with sabr, patience and trust in Allah (Quran 67:2, 2:155). Palliative care can relieve suffering without hastening death, and some Muslims argue that withholding treatment may be acceptable if it only prolongs suffering with no reasonable hope of survival. Non-religious perspectives hold different views on when a person ceases to exist, stress autonomy and quality of life, the right to die, and rational, informed decisions, and call for a clear legal framework to protect patients and healthcare providers.

Find the common ground

A hospital chaplaincy team is writing a leaflet for families. Select the THREE statements that many Christians and many Muslims could BOTH accept.

  • Easing pain for someone who is dying is a good thing to offer
  • Serious illness does not take away the value of a life
  • Nobody should set out to bring a life to an early close
  • Each person should be free to pick the moment they die
  • Great suffering shows that a life is no longer worth living
  • Every available treatment must continue whatever the burden

Plan an answer on the right to die

The exam statement is "Everyone has the right to decide when to die." Make the planning decisions.

  • Which perspectives should your answer use?
  • How should you use Christian teaching?
  • Which non-religious point fits this statement best?
  • How should you finish?

Complete the sixth form debate

At a debate on when life begins, a Christian speaker quotes Psalm _____ to say an embryo already has worth. A Muslim speaker explains that some Muslims place the start of life at _____, the point when the _____ is given by Allah. The same speaker adds that a hard decision should also be weighed by _____, keeping any damage as small as possible.

139:13-16 ensoulment ruh darar 8:6 birth aql fitrah

Compare two end of life answers

Choose the option in each gap to build an accurate comparison.

Weigh sanctity against autonomy

"The sanctity of life matters more than personal autonomy." Evaluate this statement, referring to Christian, Muslim and non-religious perspectives. Reach a justified judgement.

  • What Christians say a human is, with a reference from Genesis
  • Why Christians differ on abortion or on passive euthanasia
  • Muslim teaching on Quran 5:32, niyyah or darar
  • A non-religious view of autonomy or personhood
  • How each view of a human shapes its conclusion