Sensory Properties and Testing
A panel judges the food and nothing else. Learn what each of the five senses picks up, the five basic tastes, how to set up a fair testing panel, and when to use rating, ranking or a star profile.
Justify the choices, the way you are assessed
Free interactive practice on the decisions the assessment actually asks you to justify.
Start revising freeWhat you'll cover
Food is judged by five senses
Before anyone tastes a dish, they have already started to judge it. The senses work together when we choose and eat food, and the qualities they pick up are called the organoleptic properties of food. Sight takes in colour, shape, size and presentation. A burnt edge or a grey piece of meat can put someone off before the first bite. Smell reaches the aroma of food before the food reaches the mouth, and much of what we call flavour is really smell. Taste comes from receptors on the tongue, which pick up the five basic tastes. Touch reads texture in the hand and in the mouth, from crisp to creamy, and how hot or cold the food is. Hearing picks up the sounds food makes, such as the crunch of a crisp or the sizzle in a pan, which tell us about texture and freshness. Cooking changes all of these. Heat browns the outside of bread and meat, crisps pastry, softens vegetables, releases aroma, and can deepen or dull a colour: overcooked green vegetables turn from bright green to olive and go limp. Knowing what each sense notices is how a cook plans a dish people want to eat, and how a tester describes it.
Words for the tasting table
Five terms used whenever food is judged and tested. They come back in every step that follows.
Why does the curry taste of nothing?
During a tasting session one tester has a heavy cold and says a spicy curry tastes of almost nothing. What is the best explanation?
- Flavour depends heavily on aroma, and a blocked nose stops the aroma being picked up
- A cold stops the tongue detecting any of the five basic tastes
- The curry must have been made with too little spice
- Spicy food can only be tasted when it is very hot
Which sense is doing the judging?
- sight
- hearing
- touch
- smell
- taste
- A customer turns down a pale, uneven pie crust without eating any
- A tester notes the loud snap of a fresh ginger biscuit
- A cheese sauce feels gritty in the mouth
- Bread baking draws shoppers into a bakery from the street
- A soup has far too much salt in it
Sort the foods by basic taste
Each food is best known for one of the five basic tastes. Sort each into the taste it is known for.
- Honey
- A ripe banana
- Lemon juice
- Malt vinegar
- Black coffee
- Tonic water
- Ready salted crisps
- Salted pretzels
Reading a star profile
Profiling asks a panel to score several attributes of a product, each on the same scale, and then plots the average scores on a star profile, also called a star diagram. Each spoke is one attribute. The centre is 0 and the outer ring is the top score, here 5. The panel average for each attribute is marked on its spoke and the marks are joined up, so every product makes its own shape. Two products on one chart show at a glance where they differ. Here a bakery compared its current oat cookie with a reduced-sugar version. Where the two lines sit together, testers noticed no difference; where they split apart, the change in the recipe has been noticed. A star profile is useful in development work, because it shows which attributes to keep and which to work on next. On its own it does not say which product people like more: that is a question for a rating or ranking test.
Find the point to plot
Five testers scored the crunchiness of a new cereal bar out of 5. Their scores were 4, 5, 3, 4 and 4. What mean score should be plotted on the crunchiness spoke of its star profile?
Spot what the change cost
The bakery cut the sugar in its oat cookie. On this star profile the solid line is the current recipe and the dashed line is the reduced-sugar recipe. Tap the TWO attributes where the reduced-sugar recipe scored lower.
Rating against ranking
Profiling describes products. Two other styles of test ask what testers think of them: rating and ranking. Both can be used for one attribute, such as sweetness, or for overall liking. Whichever is used, testers need precise descriptive words: crisp, crumbly, tangy, bland or aromatic tell a cook something, while nice or lovely tell them nothing.
Choose words a cook can use
A panel sheet asks testers to describe the texture and flavour of a lemon flapjack. Tap the THREE words that give the cook useful sensory detail.
- chewy
- nice
- tangy
- OK
- crumbly
- yummy
- good
Setting up a fair testing panel
A testing panel only gives useful results if every sample gets a fair chance. The aim is for testers to judge the food and nothing else. The space: a quiet area, away from cooking smells, where testers work on their own so they cannot see or hear what anyone else thinks. The samples: an equal portion of each, all equally warm or equally chilled, on matching plates or cups. Each is labelled with a random code, such as a three-digit number or a symbol, never a name like Homemade or Brand X, so testers are not swayed by what they expect. Between samples: water or a plain cracker to clear the palate, so one flavour does not carry over into the next. The testers: enough of them for a pattern to show, told what to do but not what to expect, and checked for allergies and food intolerances first. The results sheet: clear instructions, the test style to use and room for descriptive words. The scores can then be averaged and shown as a chart or a star profile, which makes them evidence when a dish is evaluated.
Run the panel in order
Put these stages of running a sensory testing panel in a sensible order.
- Choose the test style and prepare the results sheet
- Code each sample with a random number
- Serve equal portions, all at one temperature
- Testers taste each sample, clearing the palate between them
- Collect the sheets and average the scores
- Present the results as a chart or star profile
Find the flaws in this panel
A Year 10 class tests its own pizza against a shop-bought one. Select the TWO set-up choices that will bias the results.
- The plates are labelled Homemade and Shop
- Testers sit round one table and discuss each slice as they go
- Each tester has a glass of water to sip between samples
- Every slice is cut the same size and served warm
Plan the sauce test
Priya has made three tomato pasta sauces. She wants each tester to put them in order, from favourite to least favourite, so she chooses a _____ test. She labels the pots 274, 519 and 836 rather than A, B and C, because _____ numbers give no hint of order or of which sauce is hers. Every pot is kept at one _____, so no sauce seems stronger just by being hotter, and testers have _____ to sip between pots. One tester describes sauce 519 as rich and savoury, picking up the _____ taste of slow-cooked tomatoes.
Pick the right test
Each food business has a different question. Choose the test style that answers it, then think about why.
- A school canteen wants pupils to put four new wraps in order, from most to least liked. Which test fits?
- A crisp maker changed its frying oil and wants to know exactly how crunchiness, saltiness and colour have shifted. Which test fits?
- A café wants to know how much customers like its new soup, on a scale from dislike very much to like very much. Which test fits?
Plan a sensory test for a new soup
A student has made a reduced-salt version of a vegetable soup and wants to know how it compares with the original. Explain how they should set up and run a sensory test, and how they should use the results.
- Which test style, or styles, fit the question
- How to set up a fair panel
- How to stop testers being biased
- Precise words for describing soup
- How to present and use the results